If you using it while cycling, the OpenFit won't interfere with the positioning as long as it's not an aero-helmet (the one that covers your ears and with cool visor at the front), you certainly can't wear them on a fullface mountain biking helmet or anything that covers the back of your head and cover your ears, like a motorcycle helmet. However as the unit hook over the helix (that top part of the ear), be wary of the unit when you remove your helmet as the strap may pull it off, or if the strap sits in the way and hook on the battery pack behind your ear, it may cause other issues (dislodged, sound unclear due to movement of unit relative to the battery pack), so perhaps reconsider it if you want to use it for cycling or any activities requiring you to wear a helmet.
|
How the battery pack and the hoop sits behind your ear. If your wear spectacles and has a loop type of specs, it may cause some real-estate on the helix of your ear
|
Fitting - does it really work when running?
I was skeptical as the unit hooks over the ear and afraid that it may bounce off or bounces around the external ears. After 5 runs, 4 at easy pace and one fartlek, i can say this is absolutely debunked. It doesn't move or slip when dry or when it's wet with my sweat. It doesn't move away when i try to activate the Touch control. The only thing that will dislodge the unit is if you pulled the unit from the bottom of the battery pack upwards - it slides right off the top of the ear. So, be careful if you have long hair or your helmet strap rest on part of the OpenFit or the movement of you putting your hood (jacket) over your head or adjusting a cap that rest near the back of your ears move it out of place.
|
If you avertedly hooked the bottom/battery pack (red arrow) and move it upward (yellow arrow direction), the unit slides right off |
One thing about the OpenFit that did not have advantage over the Open-series is the lack of head-loop. With my OpenRun Pro, i can hook and secure the unit over my neck and it will stay there even when i am motorbiking (as the unit doesn't folds into my pouch). So the only way to transport them is in their Charging Case, which meant you can't carry them independently if your commute or when you aren't hooking over your ears, you may risk losing them.
|
OpenRun Pro looped over my neck securely |
Sound - Else we won't be talking about this
If regret Number 2 and number 4 isn't enough to tell you about the sound quality, i do not know how much more you want me to drive the knife into my ears to let my regrets known. (this is metaphor only, i am not making myself deaf)
Having said that, a reminder that I should not compare the Bone Conduction to in-ear or over-ear headphones, as much as I should not compared OpenFit to OpenRun Pro. The sound source delivery is two totally different method.
My songs of choices are as basic as these two playlist in my Spotify here and here
Lets just say that the quality of the sound and music produced is a step up from using bone conduction, and just slightly under using in-ear monitor or over ear headphones. Only reason it loses out to the in-ear and over ear is sound isolation. Obviously the choices for open-ear concept is to hear your surrounding while still able to enjoy music, podcast, conversation and be safe. This feature or ability to do this has alone trump over everything else except if you are looking for Active Noise Cancelling (ANC) features, which you should not be using if you are exercising in a traffic area.
|
How it looked from the front - pretty stealth |
The dual-microphones is situated at the top portion of the driver unit. Compared to the Pro that has 2 mics on each side, the Fit has one mic on each side. With the AI-Noise Cancelling for voice, I can verify that whoever I talked to on the phone or laptop has no issue hearing me. As I do not take calls when I am driving or in a heavily human-traffic area, I can verify that the person on the other end could not hear my background noise such as my dogs' barking, the fan whoosing noise, or the kettle boiling downstairs. In this sense, the AI did work. How much they are different to the Pro, I have no idea as I do not have the right condition to test it.
As shared in my previous review, sound quality wise, the best would be streaming from phone or laptop/computer BUT must be using the HEADPHONE function (see above), followed by from my Garmin and lastly from the computer/laptop as HEADSET function.
This is because the quality is significantly impacted by the sound codec of your device and limited by what Shokz can process. In this case, OpenFit uses sub-band codec or SBC which allow up to 300kbps transfer rate. This is also the most general codec compatible with all Bluetooth transmission, at the expense of quality.
The Shokz is compatible with profiles such as A2DP (high quality audio signals profile), AVRCP (remote control profile for sending command such as play, skip, pause etc), HSP (Headset profile aka to be used for communication) and HFP (handsfree profile).
Being TWS earphone meant that you can have the option to just use ONE side at any time and still carry on your daily work. Not too bad if you are planning to extend the battery life by another 7 hours by using one side at a time.
About IP54 Protection
The IP protection of OpenFit is lesser than the Pro version. The OpenRun Pro is IP55 and the OpenFit is IP54.
IP stands for International Protection (rating). It comes with two numbers and an optional letter. It defines the degree of protection against solid contact and water in electrical enclosures.
|
IP54, and sufficient for the purpose and intent of the unit |
The first digit defines the level of protection the enclosure provide against access to hazardous parts such as electrical contacts, moving parts, and ingress of solid objects (like dust, sand, finger)
The second digit refers to liquid protection against well, water or liquid, generally.
The bigger the number, the better the protection. Naturally the IP55 would meant better protection versus IP54.
- IP55 protection against limited dust ingress and protected from low-pressure water jets from all direction
- IP54 protection against limited dust ingress and protected from water splashes (read: sweat and well, rinsing or just water splashes)
For the purpose of testing, yes, I have taken the OpenFit to shower after my run. Trickling water over the unit causes no significant issue except the touch function goes haywire and the air-vents on the top and bottom gets saturated with water and render the sound to be limited to just vocal/midrange.
OK for washing or cleaning after exercise. Not ok for shower.
Looking at it, IP54 is sufficient protection taking into account splashes of water from heavy rain or sweat on typical exercise. Should not have issue and do not submerge the unit in water and make sure to empty your pocket if you are the type to keep your earphones/wireless buds in your pocket (remember i say above the unit is hard to keep outside the charging case without risk of losing it?)
The Touch is Touchy
I am a fan of real button. Tactile feel you can press. OpenFit doesn't has them. And my first usage of it was a challenge.
|
Remember the Two-Dots and that Dash? |
On default, tapping them twice will play/stop the music. It was frustrating as I wasn't sure if my finger did touch the two-dots or the dash (separately on right and left respectively). I got the music paused when running one moment, and then playing again another moment. Sometimes, i can't get any button touch to work and all I hear is a beep.
I can't find the volume button because they are none. I can't skip the track because the default action for both touch button was well - play/pause.
I then opened the Shokz app to see what I can tweak from there and find the best possible combination.
|
The selection on what Double Tap can do |
For the option of Double Tap, I went for option 2 which is Play/Pause for left, and Next for right. And for Press-Hold, i went for the Volume Up (right) and Down (left). Seems to be the most workable combination. |
Press-Hold option |
I was hoping that Shokz will flip the Double Tap and have the Next on the left like on the Open-series multifunction button. This way, it will harmonise their product control and make it easy for existing user to transition.
The control work perfectly fine when you are not exercising or bouncing with movement. It was a challenge to actually place the finger tip on the raised part of the OpenFit (2-Dots and the Dash) to perform the actions. I either paused the songs, and unable to play it again (and has to use the control on the watch), or I inevitably changed the songs while trying to increase the volume - because I was bouncing in movement, and the second touch to raise the volume is registered as a double tap (and hence change the track playing).
Also, because I took it into shower to test the functionality with splashes of water, the touch could activate by itself and you get random results depending on how the water drop "touched" the unit. So, if you are running through a water station and decided to pour a cup of ice water or squeeze a sponge over your head, be aware that the water could mess with the touch control.
Otherwise, when the Touch function works, it's fine.
|
Yes, a big Yay! |
Long Term ReviewI have this unit for a month on loan thanks to Shokz Malaysia (Nove Marketing) and will be using this as much as I can to imitate real user usage as much as possible. So, back to regret number 1, yes, at this moment I should had opted for the OpenFit as my 2023-2024 entitlement.
TL:DR
Pros:
- Significant better sound reproduction than bone conduction
- Open ear concept allow you can hear your surroundings and still able to have a conversation while running or cycling or in the gym. Beyond sports-usage, the ability to hear your water boiling, fire alarm and other surrounding noises.
- Less potential for in-ear infection or impacted ear-wax as it does not go into the ear. The OpenFit sit outside the external ear and it gives impression it is an in-ear, but it isn't. No sweat or heating/hot issue as the unit doesn't sit in the ear canal or has the earpad covering like the traditional headphones.
- Comfortable fit super light. You may only feel it's there after more than 5 hours of usage as the unit presses against part of your external ear.
Cons:
- Some chances of losing the unit as it hooks over your ear that can get caught in your hood, cap or even your hair as you flip/adjust
- Sound leakage if you bump the sound too high. It is a mini-speaker after all. If you are in a quiet environment or taking a confidential call/privacy matters, it is best to lower the volume or find a more secure place.
- Touch control can be improved
Based on the four regrets I noted above (well, which is actually the plus points of the product), the OpenFit is a very good choice if you are looking for something with good sound, mobile, not in your ears and want something good for sports. |
For all it's worth, this is a really good Open-ear TWS for sports |
This unit of Shokz OpenFit is provided to me on loan by Shokz Malaysia and Nove Marketing. The unit retail for RM899.00 and comes with 2-years warranty. To purchase, please click this link.
No comments:
Post a Comment